Frugal Foo

Foo Thinking Money"Money can't buy me love"... But everything else is in this blog.

Paying the Price When Petrol Pumps are "Not in Use"

It really bugs me when I've waited for the low end of the petrol price cycle before I pull in to a petrol station to fill my car, which by then is running only on fumes and special words of encouragement from the driver, only to be confronted with "Not in Use" or similar signs on the nozzles.  On principle I will leave that petrol station and move on to another one risking running out of fuel on the way.  But I am sure there will be others who actually have better things to do rather than touring petrol stations, and will fill up with whatever fuel is available often at a higher price.  We have no way of knowing if there is really a fault with these pumps, but so often it seems to work in the favour of the petrol retailer and not the consumer.


Not normally a fan of current affairs TV programs such as A Current Affair (ACA), I couldn't help but stay tuned after the Channel 9 news last night when ACA introduced a piece about what they call a petrol scandal.  The report depicted several petrol stations where some or all of the cheapest petrol nozzles were posted with signs reading "Not in Use".  At some petrol stations,  it was the cheapest petrol, Unleaded 91 which was not in use, leaving only the more expensive premium unleaded options available to motorists.  In other cases, it was the cheapest non-ethanol blended product, Unleaded 95, which was not in use.  This means drivers with older cars that won't tolerate ethanol in the fuel, or modern sports cars which must use Premium Unleaded, are left only with the most expensive Unleaded 98 option.

The reporter then proceeded to defy the "Not in Use" signage, picking up the nozzle and drawing fuel into her cars fuel tank, demonstrating that the pumps were not out of order, as we might assume.  Responses from fuel retailers as to why this was the case are posted on the ACA website.   It should be pointed out that we don't know if the fuel the reporter merrily filled her car with was contaminated in some way, or the pump was calibrated incorrectly, or did not connect with the computer or any such fault which would have made the pump appear to work, but be quite rightly taken out of service.  But according to ACA, the Not in Use signs were "never on the most expensive petrol".

The conclusion to make from all this is that there is nothing to stop fuel retailers profiting at the expense of the unwary consumer, by closing off the low cost fuel options and leaving only expensive fuels on offer.  At the very least, the consumer is inconvenienced after having pulled up only to find they must either move on, or just fill up with the expensive fuel.

In previous posts I've explained my opinion on the lack of value for money of expensive premium unleaded and cheap but poor value ethanol blend fuels.  I always fill my car with regular unleaded 91 fuel.  I don't like being pressured to buy expensive premium fuel.

The response to ACA from the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) reads;
"Generally speaking, what retailers choose to sell and when they choose to sell it is a matter for them. This is also the case for petrol retailers. However, in making those choices, petrol retailers need to be honest and truthful in their representations as to the availability of supply."

I have to agree that I'd rather live in a world where a business is free to sell what ever (legal) products they choose at whatever prices they choose, and let competition weed out the bad players.  But a sign which simply reads "Not in Use" is misleading to the customer.  Perhaps it should read "Contaminated", or "Not for Sale", so consumers can judge whether or not to return to that business.  Any business which represents itself to be a "petrol" station which does not offer a basic type of petrol, like regular unleaded, should either not open or display clear signage out front before motorists take a detour off the main road and onto the premises where they will inevitably be disappointed.

The ACA report appeared to be limited to petrol stations in New South Whales.  My experience in Melbourne has been similar.  I'd be interested to see comments from anyone else in Australia or around the world for that matter, who has struck this similar problem, and wondered if the petrol / gas / service station manager is playing a little game with you that one way or another, you can't win.

Related Posts

Premium Unleaded vs Unleaded
E10 vs Unleaded



Anonymous said...

Yer same shit here in North Melbourne. Ghey.

10 May 2012 at 07:20

Unknown said...

Hi "you'll thank me later"
Thank you for you comment. ;)
It's happened to me on Punt Rd.

10 May 2012 at 08:25

Unknown said...

I Was Curious If You Ever Thought Of Changing The Layout Of Your Site? article Its Very Well Written; I Love What Youve Got To Say. But Maybe You Could A Little More In The Way Of Content So People Could Connect With It Better. Youve Got An Awful Lot Of Text For Only Having One Or 2 Pictures. Maybe You Could Space It Out Better?

13 May 2014 at 13:31

Manh Khang said...

Nếu bạn đang muốn đăng tin bán nhà hay bán đất hoặc bạn muốn mua nhà hay đất nha dat xinh thì hãy đến với chúng tôi rao vat mien phi, với chất lương hàng đầu chúng tôi sẽ giúp các bạn , đăng tin và xem các khu vực nhà đất gò vấp giá rẻ, nhà đất quận 9 giá rẻ, nhà đất thủ đức giá rẻ , nhà đất bình tân giá rẻ , nhà đất tân phú giá rẻ , nhà đất tân bình giá rẻ và các khu vực khác trên toàn quốc với uy tín và hiệu quả cao khi bạn đến với chúng tôi.

18 April 2015 at 01:29

Unknown said...

dddd0928louis vuitton,
herve leger sale,
air force one shoes,
tory burch shoes,
minnesota vikings,
dallas cowboys,
cheap ugg boots,
chicago bears,
moncler outlet,
cleveland cavaliers,
prada handbags,
north face jackets,north face,the north face,northface,north face outlet,north face jackets clearance,the north face
chicago blackhawks,
pandora charms,
louis vuitton outlet online,
adidas outlet store,
ray ban sunglasses outlet,ray ban usa,ray ban sunglasses,ray ban,rayban,ray bans,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban,ray ban outlet,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,
michael kors outlet online,
north face outlet online,

28 September 2015 at 16:14

Unknown said...

ray ban,
cheap nba jerseys,
chanel handbags,
polo ralph lauren,
north face jackets,
tiffany outlet,
herve leger,
coach outlet store,
coach outlet online,
adidas wings,
vans shoes,
nike air force 1,
louis vuitton outlet,
ugg uk,
michael kors outlet,
michael kors wallet,
ralph lauren outlet,
karen millen dresses,
michael kors outlet,
swarovski jewelry,
true religion jeans,
futbol baratas,
christian louboutin,
dansko outlet,
ray ban sunglasses,

6 October 2015 at 12:30

Post a comment